Clover Markup Exposed: What Interchange Plus 1.67% Really Costs
Clover Markup Exposed: What Interchange Plus 1.67% Really Costs
If you have been shopping for a Clover POS system, you have probably heard a reseller pitch you on "interchange-plus pricing." It sounds transparent. It sounds fair. They tell you: "You pay the actual interchange rate plus our small markup."
Then you see the markup: interchange plus 1.67% + $0.25.
That word "plus" makes it sound like a small addition. It is not. A 1.67% markup is enormous, and when you do the math on what it actually costs your business per year, the numbers are staggering.
Clover holds a 3.9-star rating on G2 (420 reviews) and a 3.8-star rating on Capterra (510 reviews) -- the lowest scores among major POS platforms. The number-one reason: the reseller model that leads to wildly inconsistent pricing and support quality. This article shows you exactly how that inconsistency hurts your bottom line.
How Interchange-Plus Pricing Is Supposed to Work
Before we expose the markup, let us make sure you understand the model. Interchange-plus is the most transparent pricing structure in payment processing. Here is how it works:
Every card transaction has three cost components:
1. Interchange fee -- Set by Visa, Mastercard, Discover, and Amex. Paid to the card-issuing bank. You cannot negotiate this. It varies by card type, transaction method, and merchant category. Typical range: 1.4% to 2.5%.
2. Assessment fee -- Set by the card networks. Usually 0.13% to 0.15%. Also non-negotiable.
3. Processor markup -- This is what your processor charges on top of interchange and assessments. This is the only negotiable component.
On an interchange-plus statement, you see all three components broken out separately. You can verify the interchange charges against Visa and Mastercard's published schedules. You can see exactly what your processor charges in markup. Total transparency.
This is a good pricing model -- when the markup is reasonable.
A competitive interchange-plus markup for a small to mid-size business processing $20,000 to $100,000 per month typically ranges from 0.10% to 0.40% plus $0.05 to $0.10 per transaction. Quality processors with efficient operations and reasonable margins operate in this range profitably.
A 1.67% markup is four to sixteen times higher than a competitive rate.
The Math on Interchange Plus 1.67%
Let us run the numbers on a real business scenario. We will use a retail business processing $30,000 per month with a typical card mix.
Average Interchange Cost
For a retail business, the weighted average interchange rate across all card types (debit, credit, rewards, corporate) is approximately 1.75%. Add assessments of 0.14%, and your base cost before processor markup is about 1.89%.
With a 1.67% Markup
| Component | Rate | Monthly Cost on $30,000 |
|---|---|---|
| Interchange (avg) | 1.75% | $525.00 |
| Assessments | 0.14% | $42.00 |
| Processor markup | 1.67% | $501.00 |
| Per-transaction fee ($0.25 x 600 transactions) | -- | $150.00 |
| Total | 3.56% | $1,218.00 |
Your effective rate: 4.06% (including the per-transaction fees).
Your processor markup as a dollar amount: $651 per month ($501 percentage markup + $150 per-transaction fees).
With a Competitive 0.25% Markup
| Component | Rate | Monthly Cost on $30,000 |
|---|---|---|
| Interchange (avg) | 1.75% | $525.00 |
| Assessments | 0.14% | $42.00 |
| Processor markup | 0.25% | $75.00 |
| Per-transaction fee ($0.08 x 600 transactions) | -- | $48.00 |
| Total | 2.14% | $690.00 |
Your effective rate: 2.30%.
Your processor markup as a dollar amount: $123 per month.
The Difference
| Clover Reseller (1.67%) | Competitive Processor (0.25%) | Difference | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | $1,218 | $690 | $528/month |
| Annual cost | $14,616 | $8,280 | $6,336/year |
| 3-year cost | $43,848 | $24,840 | $19,008 over 3 years |
That is not a rounding error. A 1.67% markup versus a 0.25% markup costs this $30,000-per-month business an additional $6,336 per year. Over a typical three-year equipment lifecycle, that is $19,008 in excess processing costs.
And the larger your volume, the worse it gets. At $50,000 per month, the annual overpayment jumps to approximately $10,560. At $75,000 per month, it exceeds $15,800 per year.
Why Clover Markups Are So High
The answer is in the G2 and Capterra reviews. The most common complaints across 930 combined reviews tell the story:
The Reseller Model
Clover is manufactured by Fiserv (formerly First Data), one of the largest payment processing companies in the world. But Fiserv does not sell Clover directly to most merchants. Instead, they distribute through a network of resellers -- Independent Sales Organizations (ISOs) and agents.
G2's top complaint: "Reseller model leads to inconsistent pricing and support." Capterra echoes this: "Resellers over-promise and under-deliver."
Each reseller sets their own markup. There is no standard Clover processing rate. One reseller might quote interchange plus 0.50%. Another quotes interchange plus 1.67%. A third quotes a flat rate of 3.5%. The merchant has no way to know what is "normal" without shopping around.
The reseller's income comes almost entirely from the processing markup. The higher the markup they can get you to agree to, the more money they make. A 1.67% markup on $30,000 in monthly volume generates $501 per month for the reseller -- over $6,000 per year from a single merchant.
Hidden Processing Fees From Third-Party ISOs
G2's second most common complaint: "Hidden processing fees from third-party ISOs." These are fees beyond the quoted interchange-plus rate that appear on statements but were never clearly disclosed:
- Monthly minimum fees ($25 if your processing volume does not generate enough in fees)
- PCI compliance fees ($9.95 to $19.95 per month)
- Statement fees ($7.95 to $14.95 per month)
- Batch settlement fees ($0.25 per batch)
- Annual fees ($79 to $199)
- Regulatory compliance fees ($4.95 to $9.95 per month)
These fees can add $50 to $100 per month on top of the already-inflated markup. On our $30,000-per-month example, that pushes the true effective rate even higher.
Locked Into the Fiserv Ecosystem
G2 complaint number three: "Locked into Fiserv ecosystem for payment processing." Clover hardware only processes payments through Fiserv's processing platform. Even if you find a processor offering better rates, you cannot use them with your Clover equipment unless they process through Fiserv's backend.
This means your "choice" of processor is limited to resellers who all use the same backend platform. Competition is restricted, and markups stay high because merchants cannot easily bring in an outside processor.
Expensive, Proprietary Hardware
G2 complaint number four: "Hardware is expensive and proprietary." Clover devices range from $599 for a Clover Flex to $1,799 for a Clover Station Duo. These devices only work with Clover software and Fiserv processing. If you switch to a non-Fiserv processor, the hardware becomes useless.
Capterra adds: "Leasing contracts trap small businesses." Many Clover resellers push equipment leases instead of purchases, adding another $49 to $79 per month to your costs for hardware you never own.
How to Tell If You Are Overpaying
Pull your last three Clover processing statements and look for these numbers:
Step 1: Calculate Your Effective Rate
Add up every fee on your statement -- processing fees, transaction fees, monthly fees, PCI fees, everything. Divide by your total processing volume. This is your effective rate.
- Under 2.5%: You have a reasonable deal.
- 2.5% to 3.0%: You are likely overpaying on markup. Worth shopping around.
- 3.0% to 3.5%: You are significantly overpaying. Switch as soon as possible.
- Over 3.5%: You are being taken advantage of. This is urgent.
Step 2: Identify the Markup
If your statement shows interchange-plus pricing, find the markup line. Anything over 0.50% + $0.15 for a business processing more than $10,000 per month is above market rate.
Step 3: Count the Junk Fees
List every fee on your statement that is not directly related to processing a transaction. Monthly fees, annual fees, PCI fees, compliance fees, statement fees, batch fees. Add them up. If the total exceeds $30 per month, you are paying fees that competitive processors either do not charge or include in their markup.
Your Options
Option 1: Negotiate With Your Current Reseller
Armed with this information, call your Clover reseller and tell them you know your markup is above market rate. Ask them to reduce it to 0.25% to 0.40% + $0.08 to $0.10. Some will negotiate. Many will not, because their business model depends on the high markup.
Option 2: Find a Different Clover Reseller
Since Clover is sold through multiple resellers, you can switch to a different reseller with lower markups while keeping your Clover hardware. This requires changing your processing account but not your equipment.
Option 3: Switch to Non-Proprietary Equipment
The most impactful long-term move is switching to equipment that is not locked to a single processing ecosystem. Terminal brands like PAX, Dejavoo, and Ingenico work with virtually any processor, giving you the freedom to shop for the best rate without worrying about hardware compatibility.
This does mean replacing your Clover hardware, which is a real cost. But compare that one-time cost ($300 to $800 for a quality terminal) to the annual overpayment of $6,000+ on inflated markups. The equipment pays for itself in the first month.
What a Fair Deal Looks Like
Here is what you should expect from a quality processor in 2026:
- Interchange-plus markup: 0.10% to 0.40% + $0.05 to $0.10 per transaction (depending on volume)
- Monthly fees: $0 to $15 (for statement and PCI compliance, if any)
- Contract length: Month-to-month
- Equipment: Purchased outright, processor-agnostic
- Support: Live phone support during business hours
- Transparency: Every fee disclosed upfront, no surprises on statements
If your Clover reseller cannot match these terms, they are not competitive.
The Bottom Line
"Interchange-plus" is not automatically a good deal. The markup matters enormously, and Clover's reseller model creates a marketplace where markups vary wildly and merchants often have no idea they are overpaying.
A 1.67% markup is not a small addition. It is a massive surcharge that costs a $30,000-per-month business over $6,300 per year in excess fees. That money goes to your reseller's profit margin, not to improving your business.
Clover's 3.9-star G2 rating and 3.8-star Capterra rating -- the lowest among major POS platforms -- reflect this reality. The hardware is decent. The reseller pricing model is broken.
Get Your Markup Analyzed for Free
Text "CLOVER" to (215) 595-6671 and send us your last Clover statement.
We will identify your exact markup, calculate how much you are overpaying, and show you what fair interchange-plus pricing looks like for your business. No obligation, just math.
At Sleft Payments, we believe your markup should be measured in tenths of a percent, not full percentage points. Transparent pricing, month-to-month terms, and equipment you own.
About the Author
Grant Denmark
CEO & Founder of Sleft LLC
Grant helps small businesses across Florida and the East Coast navigate payment processing without the jargon or the runaround. Transparent pricing, real support, no long-term contracts.
Don't get Sleft Behind
We help businesses keep more of every dollar.